FIRST TEAM OFFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Ed Dougherty | Lycoming | QB |
| Jon Thorpe | Albright | RB |
| Dennis DeRenzo | Juniata | RB |
| Joe Gillespie | Lycoming | C |
| Aaron Johnson | Lebanon Valley | G |
| Matt Carretti | Susquehanna | G |
| Ed Terwilliger | Lycoming | T |
| Craig Downey | Moravian | T |
| Ray Shelley, Jr. | Juniata | WR |
| Joe Sweeley | Widener | WR |
| Chris McCarthy | Susquehanna | TE |
| John Phillips | Lycoming | K |
| Dennis DeRenzo | Juniata | P |
FIRST TEAM DEFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Joe Emrick | Lycoming | |
| Dave Ellison | Widener | |
| Brian Giachetti | Juniata | |
| Rick Bealer | Lycoming | |
| Cory Mabry | Susquehanna | |
| Dave Bell | Widener | |
| Dean Koffman | Lycoming | |
| Keith Henry | Susquehanna | |
| Mark McKenna | Widener | |
| Chad McNaughton | Lebanon Valley | |
| Bill Small | Lycoming | |
Coach of the Year: Frank Girardi, Lycoming
Player of the Year: Ed Dougherty, Lycoming
SECOND TEAM OFFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Tim Ford | Delaware Valley | QB |
| Bill Posavek | Juniata | RB |
| Steve Vajda | Lebanon Valley | RB |
| Steve Hykes | Delaware Valley | C |
| Mike Hogue | Juniata | G |
| John Phillips | Susquehanna | G |
| Brian Wright | Susquehanna | T |
| Kyle Sheckler | Wilkes | T |
| Matt Harvey | Lycoming | TE |
| Brian Wassell | Lebanon Valley | WR |
| Paul Holloman | Lycoming | WR |
| Tim Cunniff | Moravian | K |
| Bill Hogan | Delaware Valley | P |
SECOND TEAM DEFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Mark Lesniewski | Susquehanna | DE |
| Joe Souders | Lebanon Valley | DE |
| Dave Samuel | Delaware Valley | DB |
| Tom Hartman | Lycoming | DB |
| Bill Umbenhaver | Moravian | DB |
| Dave Wood | Widener | DB |
| Tom Kellett | Delaware Valley | DL |
| Rick Harbo | Moravian | DL |
| Eric Holscher | Widener | DL |
| Jon DeFoe | Lycoming | LB |
| Russ Parsons | Moravian | LB |
HONORABLE MENTION
| Joe DeSimone | Lycoming | WR |
| Matt Fulham | Juniata | TE |
| Steve Tone | Moravian | G |
| Matt Carlin | Moravian | G |
| Steve Wagner | Delaware Valley | T |
| Darrin Kenney | Lycoming | T |
| Newt Holobinko | Juniata | C |
| Jason Miller | Juniata | QB |
| Steve Cianci | Widener | QB |
| John Hall | Susquehanna | P |
| Mike Hirschmann | Delaware Valley | LB |
| Scott Russell | Widener | LB |
| Greg Vella | Albright | DL |
| Steve Brunner | Juniata | DL |
| Smokey Glover | Juniata | DL |
| Mike Porecca | Albright | DE |