COMMONWEALTH LEAGUE
FIRST TEAM OFFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Sean Keville | Moravian | QB |
| Anthony Gossette | Widener | RB |
| George Jones | Widener | RB |
| Jeff Roy | Moravian | WR |
| Boonta Kheuangthirath | Widener | WR |
| Ed Donley | Lebanon Valley | TE |
| David French | Lebanon Valley | OL |
| James Hickey | Susquehanna | OL |
| Joe Balint | Susquehanna | OL |
| Dave Braksator | Widener | OL |
| Pete Garzia | Widener | OL |
| Matt Bendekovits | Moravian | OL |
| Dennis Unger | Albright | K |
| Ryan Currie | Lebanon Valley | P |
FIRST TEAM DEFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Mike Digrigoli | Susquehanna | DE |
| O.J. McElroy | Widener | DE |
| Ray Minerovic | Susquehanna | DL |
| Dan Ademski | Widener | DL |
| Jeff Puksyn | Moravian | DL |
| Tim Boyne | Susquehanna | LB |
| Blaise Coleman | Widener | LB |
| Clarence Giles | Widener | LB |
| Ed Boyer | Lebanon Valley | DB |
| Antonio Moore | Widener | DB |
| Mike Gerhart | Susquehanna | DB |
| Joe Scarpati | Widener | DB |
| Tyrone Croom | Susquehanna | PR |
| Robsawne Little | Widener | KR |
SECOND TEAM OFFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Erick Hackenberg | Susquehanna | QB |
| Tyrone Croom | Susquehanna | RB |
| Don Duffy | Susquehanna | RB |
| Ryan Ditze | Albright | WR |
| C.J. Hoffman | Susquehanna | WR |
| Steve Cavanaugh | Juniata | TE |
| Jeff Bell | Widener | OL |
| Tom Richards | Juniata | OL |
| Shane lamas | Moravian | OL |
| Steve U'Selis | Moravian | OL |
| Brian Hamill | Widener | K |
| Chad Kurtz | Moravian | P |
SECOND TEAM DEFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Rob Plank | Juniata | DE |
| Steve Lowalski | Juniata | DL |
| Chad Zaring | Juniata | DL |
| Dave Herkalo | Moravian | DL |
| Edwin Heisey | Lebanon Valley | DL |
| Jim Dague | Moravian | LB |
| Cory Mattern | Lebanon Valley | LB |
| Bob Hennessey | Moravian | DB |
| Len Ebel | Susquehanna | DB |
FREEDOM LEAGUE
FIRST TEAM OFFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Boo Perry | Wilkes | QB |
| Elijah Powell | Wilkes | RB |
| Mike McCarty | Lycoming | RB |
| Steve Verton | Lycoming | WR |
| Mike Gundersdorf | Wilkes | WR |
| Vic Moncato | FDU-Madison | WR |
| Bill Butkey | Wilkes | TE |
| Matt Solt | Delaware Valley | OL |
| Mike Downey | Lycoming | OL |
| Jason Majiros | Wilkes | OL |
| Keith Fox | Wilkes | OL |
| John Chambers | FDU-Madison | OL |
| Joel O'Donnell | Wilkes | K |
| Vic Moncato | FDU-Madison | P |
FIRST TEAM DEFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Lyle Wesneski | Lycoming | DE |
| Jake Cole | Wilkes | DE |
| Walt Tobash | Delaware Valley | DL |
| Mike Gibson | FDU-Madison | DL |
| Chris Cunningham | Wilkes | DL |
| Ed Schon | FDU-Madison | LB |
| Chad Ormond | King's | LB |
| Bob Delbo | Wilkes | LB |
| Scott Miller | Lycoming | DB |
| Ben McKeown | Wilkes | DB |
| Dennis Bowers | King's | DB |
| Mike Gavio | FDU-Madison | DB |
| Ryan Alston | Wilkes | KR |
SECOND TEAM OFFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Jason Schneider | FDU-Madison | QB |
| John Myers | King's | RB |
| Brad Lower | Delaware Valley | RB |
| Anthony Diorio | FDU-Madison | TE |
| Don Adams | FDU-Madison | OL |
| Pete Dougherty | FDU-Madison | OL |
| Tom Ralicke | Lycoming | P |
SECOND TEAM DEFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Matt Metz | Delaware Valley | DE |
| Anthony Eosso | FDU-Madison | DL |
| Carmen DeRose | FDU-Madison | LB |
| Lou Atkinson | Wilkes | LB |
| Demon Roxas | FDU-Madison | DB |
| Frank Pikul | King's | DB |
| Joe Woodward | Wilkes | DB |
| Mark Cahill | FDU-Madison | KR |