COMMONWEALTH LEAGUE
FIRST TEAM OFFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Bryan Snyder | Albright | Quarterback |
| Jim Rivello | Juniata | Running Back |
| Don Duffy | Susquehanna | Running Back |
| Leon Payne | Widener | Running Back |
| Ryan Ditze | Albright | Wide Receiver |
| Jason Falvo | Juniata | Wide Receiver |
| Ben Reph | Albright | Tight End |
| Ed Baker | Albright | Offensive Line |
| Sean McGinty | Albright | Offensive Line |
| Jeremy Brummet | Juniata | Offensive Line |
| Tom Richards | Juniata | Offensive Line |
| Jason Hotchkiss | Lebanon Valley | Offensive Line |
| Joe Balint | Susquehanna | Offensive Line |
| Jeff Kuc | Widener | Offensive Line |
| Jeff Noonan | Widener | Kicker |
FIRST TEAM DEFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Shawn Stratz | Albright | Defensive Line |
| Chad Zaring | Juniata | Defensive Line |
| Jeff Pukszyn | Moravian | Defensive Line |
| Jim Keman | Albright | Defensive End |
| Aaron Hartman | Juniata | Defensive End |
| Jason Howe | Albright | Linebacker |
| Roger Wiest | Susquehanna | Linebacker |
| Clarence Giles | Widener | Linebacker |
| Bob Maro | Albright | Defensive Back |
| Mike Paciulli | Moravian | Defensive Back |
| Jeremy Zeisloft | Susquehanna | Defensive Back |
| Mark Lowman | Widener | Defensive Back |
| Jason Falvo | Juniata | Specialist |
| Jeff Perry | Albright | Punter |
Commonwealth League Player of the Year: Bryan Snyder (Albright)
Commonwealth League Coach of the Year: Ron Maier (Albright)
FREEDOM LEAGUE
FIRST TEAM OFFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Keith Cadden | Lycoming | Quarterback |
| Rob Lewis | FDU-Madison | Running Back |
| Jamie Allen | Lycoming | Running Back |
| Mike Hankins | Wilkes | Running Back |
| Steve Verton | Lycoming | Wide Receiver |
| Mike Gundersdorf | Wilkes | Wide Receiver |
| Anthony DiOrio | FDU-Madison | Tight End |
| Matt Solt | Delaware Valley | Offensive Line |
| John Chambers | FDU-Madison | Offensive Line |
| Charlie Roca | King's | Offensive Line |
| Michael Downey | Lycoming | Offensive Line |
| Jason Meyer | Lycoming | Offensive Line |
| Jason Majiros | Wilkes | Offensive Line |
| Jeff Cook | Lycoming | Kicker |
FIRST TEAM DEFENSE
| Name | School | Position |
| Steve Moraca | King's | Defensive Line |
| Shawn Bell | Lycoming | Defensive Line |
| Matt Rodarmel | Wilkes | Defensive Line |
| Carmin DeRose | FDU-Madison | Defensive End |
| JJ Fadden | Wilkes | Defensive End |
| Pete Wilson | FDU-Madison | Linebacker |
| Chad Ormond | King's | Linebacker |
| Brett Zalonis | Lycoming | Linebacker |
| John Verton | Lycoming | Defensive Back |
| Jason Logue | Lycoming | Defensive Back |
| Brad Gilmore | Lycoming | Defensive Back |
| Aaron Wilk | Wilkes | Defensive Back |
| Jose Valentin | Delaware Valley | Specialist |
| Tom Ralicke | Lycoming | Punter |
Freedom League Player of the Year: Keith Cadden (Lycoming)
Freedom League Coach of the Year: Frank Girardi (Lycoming)